Planting winter cover crops is often cited as a climate win for arable farmers – but research suggests that the potential to do much more in Europe is limited.
The advantages of cover cropping between cash crops can be numerous. Primary benefits include improved soil carbon sequestration due to increased organic matter input, as well as better soil structure and water retention. A range of crops can be planted in this way, from cereals and legumes to brassicas and herbs.
High adoption leaves little room for growth
Despite these positives, which when applied on a continental or global scale could bring significant sustainability and productivity improvements, there remain uncertainties about just how much additional cover cropping can be done. A study by researchers at Wageningen University has showed that in Europe, the potential may be modest.
Using a survey with 321 farmers, they found that 97% of farmers in the Netherlands and 89% of those in Germany were already using cover crops.
They calculated that in the Netherlands and Germany, the remaining arable land that could possibly be used for such winter sowing was 25% and 11%, respectively. This low potential was despite the fact that only 43% and 28% of the arable land in the two countries is currently sown with winter cover, as this area is limited by the proportion land which is primarily used for spring-sown crops.
Both water scarcity and abundance blocks cover crops
There are also significant additional limits to further use of the practice. Spanish farmers surveyed were not sowing cover crops at all, mainly due to water scarcity and concern over competition for limited resources between cover crops and spring-sown crops. Weather is not just a limiting factor in the Mediterranean, but farmers in the central European countries reported a different problem: soils often becoming too wet to sow cover crops.
Such conditions, as well as poor soil structure on fields, can require additional tilling and higher seeding rates which add to costs – often when farmers are already uncertain about the economic benefits of the approach.
“Taking into account agronomic factors is needed to bring greater realism to carbon sequestration potentials of soil management practices,” they commented in European Journal of Agronomy.
Co-benefits may matter more than carbon
The scientists acknowledged that because of their limited sample size and the online nature of their survey, caution should be exercised around making sweeping generalisations about the dynamics around arable farmers’ use of cover crops, while advocating for longer-term studies to track shifts over time. But they stressed that the study provides valuable insights into key drivers and constraints.
They noted that emphasising multiple co-benefits of cover cropping and not simply carbon sequestration may be attractive to farmers – particularly in regions where they face challenges with soil fertility or nitrate leaching.
“By incorporating agroecological benefits as the core of soil carbon sequestration efforts, we ensure that investments in these practices remain valuable,” the researchers added.
“Even if carbon storage falls short of expectations, the environmental and societal benefits of improved soil health can still yield meaningful outcomes, provided that policies prioritise these broader goals.”
- 97% of Dutch and 89% of German surveyed farmers already use cover crops.
- Only 25% (NL) and 11% (DE) of arable land could still take winter cover crops.
- Spanish farmers avoid cover crops due to water scarcity and competition with spring crops.
- Wet soils and poor structure raise tilling and seeding costs, weakening the business case.
- Researchers say policies should reward broader soil health benefits, not just carbon storage.
Want to read more stories like this? Sign up to our newsletter for bi-weekly updates on sustainable farming and agtech innovation.








